Been checking out small-frame revolvers recently and trying to narrow down my choices. The S&W 442 is on top of my list but I’d really like to hear how it’s performed for others before I decide. How comfortable is it? What’s the recoil like? Is it reliable? Appreciate in advance.
Thoughts on the S&W 442?
- Thread starter Rogerdat
- Start date
Sgt. Stadanko
Active member
- Joined
- Aug 2, 2025
- Messages
- 35
You should go to one of the indoor ranges that rent guns and shoot one. Being a newer model hammer less pistol, the trigger/action really sucks. Not much can be done to rectify it either.
If you’re interested in one, go try one. It may work for you.
If you’re interested in one, go try one. It may work for you.
Snowman.45
Member
- Joined
- Jul 3, 2025
- Messages
- 8
I carried a S&W j-frame of one model or another as an on-duty/off-duty BUG for most of my 37 year career. I still often carry one today. One of my current j-frames I carry is a M&P 340, very similar to the 442. They are great little revolvers for concealment. With a little polishing (preferably by a trained gunsmith) and hammer and recoil sping replacements, they are much improved. All of mine have been accurate, completely reliable and comfortable to carry. I stress that you have any improvements done by a competent gunsmith if you're not familiar with these models.
Last edited:
needsmostuff
Member
Not range guns and probably not +P guns. But if you just want something comforting in the pocket, they are one of the best.
